Menu of The Crosstown Tavern in Starlight, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Located along Hancock Highway in Starlight, PA, The Crosstown Tavern stands out as a true bar and grill gem. From the moment you step inside, the atmosphere hits just the right balance of casual comfort and lively energy, perfect for unwinding after a long day or catching up with friends over a hearty meal.

The menu offers a robust selection, with standout dishes that reflect the kitchen’s skill and dedication to classic American bar fare done well. The wings are a must-try—bursting with flavor and cooked to juicy perfection. Their Buffalo Wing Basket, priced at just $8.75, showcases a bold, tangy sauce that clings to tender meat, making it a favorite among regulars.

Deep-fried pierogies and pickles are inventive bar snacks that elevate the experience with a pleasing crunch and satisfying richness—an excellent nod to regional comfort food with a twist. Among sandwiches, the Filet Mignon Steak Sandwich and Pulled Pork Sandwich shine with quality cuts and generous portions, wrapped neatly in fresh bread that holds up without overpowering the fillings.

The deeper menu offerings impress as well. The NY Strip Steak Dinner at $17.50 and the Prime Rib Dinner for $18.75 introduce a fine-dining touch to the tavern setting, highlighting expertly cooked steaks that are juicy and well-seasoned, alongside classic sides. The Chicken Parmesan maintains authenticity with rich marinara and melted cheese piled atop tender chicken, a comforting favorite that resonates with timeless flavor.

Burgers claim a special place here, particularly the BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger and the classic Bacon Cheeseburger 1/2 Pounder at $8.00. These boast juicy patties with smoky bacon and melty cheese, delivering a satisfying bite every time. Wraps like the Buffalo Chicken and Shrimp Caesar add variety, bringing freshness and texture balance.

Customer praise underscores the tavern’s appeal: from John Cooley’s love of its "amazing food" and "great beer" to Vanessa Gonzalez’s high praise for the cheeseburger and wings, the consensus is clear—this place delivers on flavor and hospitality. The staff's friendliness and attentiveness, especially highlighted by Jack Cola's mention of the memorable bartender, enhance the dining experience beyond just the food.

Although some note that menu information online can lag, the on-site offerings remain hearty and satisfying, fulfilling the promise of a classic bar and grill with a welcoming vibe, generous portions, and dishes that invite repeat visits. The Crosstown Tavern is not just a stopover but a destination for those craving genuine, well-executed American comfort food in a warm, lively setting.